9 Comments

That last paragraph & line was perfect. The guilt and grief for all atrocities that go on in the world are hard to come to terms when it’s just luck that means we are safe and they are not.

Expand full comment

Thank you so much for this piece.

Expand full comment

I read the entire book of Deaf Republic just after it came out - the poem is equally interesting in context, because the book is a narrative collection about a community living in the wake and midst of great violence. But I also think of Wislawa Symborska's The End and the Beginning - that peace and happiness in the midst of violence (elsewhere) is always part of the human condition, that there is always violence near and far you can choose to attend to, or not, in the midst of your own happiness. Where and when do we notice violence? What cameras, whose words, draw it to our attention? How are we listening for it? How do we let our own happiness, when we have if, be our water and our iron that allows us to be strong, and not look away, and question how our own participation in oppression and liberation (hopefully more of one than the other) will shape the rest of our lives?

(thank you for so many compelling pieces of writing that seem to always inspire me to write very long comments!)

Expand full comment

Thank you. This was beautiful and devastating.

Expand full comment

This is beautiful, thank job

Expand full comment

What is it about Israel Palestine that tugs at your heart strings in such a way Pranay? I don't see any such heart wrenching writing from you concerning the Haitians, Sudanese, Rohingya, Uighurs, Hazaras, etc. Your life and billions of others' continue unaffected regardless of all these situations. Forgive me Pranay, however this piece comes off to me as rather self-serving, "look at me wanting to suffer like those in Gaza but sigh...I must live in my cozy apartment and play scrabble" This is all in good faith by the way, I await your response.

Expand full comment

Your whataboutism is so very tiresome.

There, is that attention enough.

By the way, you have terrible reading comprehension.

Think about it.

Expand full comment

Will I hear from you Pranay? You seem to 'heart' all the comments that adore you but ignore the slightest pushback haha...

Expand full comment